Elizabeth Bishop · Leaving Cert Poetry

A grandmother and child sit through a rainy afternoon, tears displaced onto a kettle, an almanac, a stove, and the poem ends exactly where it began: unresolved, with nothing named and nothing settled.

Context

Elizabeth Bishop’s father died when she was eight months old, and her mother was permanently hospitalised for mental illness when Bishop was five; Bishop was afterwards raised mainly by grandparents in Nova Scotia. Sestina, published in 1965 and collected in Questions of Travel, is widely read against this childhood, though the poem itself never states this directly, withholding explanation in the same way the grandmother and child withhold their feelings from each other. Bishop titles the poem after its own strict form rather than its content, foregrounding technical control over the emotional material it holds; the title’s own reticence enacts the poem’s larger theme of concealment. A sestina repeats the same six end-words, house, grandmother, child, stove, almanac, tears, across six stanzas in a fixed rotating order, closed by a three-line envoi that compresses all six words together.

Key Moments

The poem opens on weather, not speech, pathetic fallacy carrying grief before language does.

“September rain falls on the house.”Sestina

The grandmother’s method is stated outright in the poem’s first stanza: sound used deliberately to mask feeling.

“laughing and talking to hide her tears.”Sestina

Her own crying is folded into an impersonal seasonal pattern, an explanation she gives the almanac’s authority rather than the child directly.

“her equinoctial tears”Sestina

The viewpoint shifts to the child, who reads an ordinary kettle sound as crying, absorbing grief through observation rather than explanation.

“the teakettle’s small hard tears”Sestina

The almanac escalates from a book into a watching presence, hovering specifically over the child.

“hovers half open above the child”Sestina

An ordinary cup of tea becomes tears outright, the boldest of the poem’s substitutions.

“full of dark brown tears”Sestina

Two household objects are given actual spoken certainty about fate, authority over what has happened handed to the furniture, not to either character.

“It was to be, says the Marvel Stove.”Sestina

The child, unprompted, reproduces the poem’s own tear-motif inside a drawing, grief already passed into the child before anyone has named it.

“a man with buttons like tears”Sestina

The almanac is made to weep small moons directly into the child’s imagined garden.

“the little moons fall down like tears”Sestina

The envoi recasts tears as something to be planted, a cycle that keeps growing rather than a single, resolved event.

“Time to plant tears, says the almanac.”Sestina

The poem closes on a house that still cannot be read.

“another inscrutable house”Sestina

Do not read that final image as resolution. Another signals repetition without progress, and inscrutable denies the reader, and the grandmother, any final interpretive certainty: the poem closes exactly where it began, and nothing is resolved, the cycle of concealment simply continues into the next generation.

Key Themes

Concealment of grief runs through every stanza, sound and routine used to mask what neither generation will name aloud. Domestic ritual and objects, the kettle, the stove, the almanac, are doing the poem’s emotional work in place of speech. Fate and prophecy escalate from a private explanation into fully personified certainty, voiced by furniture rather than family. Childhood and art as processing closes the poem, but the child’s drawing does not resolve anything: it shows grief passing into the next generation before language has explained it.

Literary Devices

Every domestic object, kettle, stove, almanac, teacup, is doing emotional work; the poem’s whole method is grief displaced onto things because neither character will name it aloud. The personified objects’ spoken lines, It was to be, I know what I know, are the only moments of certainty or authority in the poem, and giving fate’s voice to the furniture rather than the grandmother is exactly how Bishop shows the adults have no answers of their own. The sestina’s six repeating end-words enact the poem’s argument formally, a structure that circles rather than progresses. The final adjective, inscrutable, is the poem’s last and most important technical choice: it denies catharsis rather than offering it.

Mood

The poem begins flat and plainly domestic, undercut immediately by suppressed grief, moves through an escalating, increasingly uncanny personification of household objects, and closes on quiet continuation rather than release or catharsis.

Conclusion

Bishop uses the poem’s own strict form, and the personification of ordinary household objects, to say what the grandmother and child cannot say to each other, showing grief as something that leaks into a house through its objects rather than through speech. Do not read the child’s drawing as hope or resolution: the house the child draws is called inscrutable, the same unreadable quality that has hung over the whole poem, and the poem ends exactly where it began, with concealment continuing rather than lifting.

Quick Links

More Elizabeth Bishop poems and notes